INTRODUCTION TO MEDITATIONBhikkhu Pesala
34 B Cambridge Road Ilford IG3 8LU
The Human Condition
Before describing how to practise Buddhist meditation it is necessary to explain its purpose. Why do people need to practise meditation and what should they aim to achieve through it? Not only Buddhists, but anyone with the right mental attitude can practise Buddhist meditation and achieve very significant benefits. However, it is not just a therapeutic technique its ultimate aim is very high, being no less than enlightenment or human perfection.
Human perfection might seem an impossible goal for most people, so it would be better to explain first about the condition from which we begin that is human imperfection. To have the right attitude to meditation we have to acknowledge the imperfection of the human condition. In the Pali language this human imperfection is called dukkha. The word dukkha is often translated as suffering. This is a correct translation but not a comprehensive one. Dukkha does mean pain or suffering i.e. physical pain, mental sorrow, grief, etc. All these things are undoubtedly painful and are therefore dukkha. However, the word dukkha also means unsatisfactoriness, discontent, unease. Even feelings of happiness and pleasure are included in the term dukkha because they are unstable and offer no real peace. When pleasure or happiness disappears one feels sad, so worldly happiness is not the most important goal for which people should strive.
All religious people recognise the imperfection or human weakness of man. In the Pali language these human weaknesses are called kilesa defilements of the mind. The three main defilements are greed (lobha), hatred (dosa) and delusion (moha).
The characteristic of lobha is the tendency of the mind to stick to an object. There are various aspects of lobha greed, lust, craving, attachment, covetousness, envy, etc. There are other less obvious aspects of lobha like conceit and bigotry; in general, holding on to ones own opinions as, This alone is the truth, all else is falsehood. Lobha is common to all unenlightened men and women of whatever religious persuasion.
The characteristic of dosa is the tendency of the mind to repel an object. The aspects of dosa like hatred, anger, ill-will and jealousy are obvious enough. Contempt, disrespect and stubbornness are also aspects of dosa.
Moha means delusion or ignorance. We are deceived by our own false perceptions of the world around us. The mind is extremely rapid, subtle and difficult to perceive, it runs after objects according to ones own particular likes and dislikes and is rarely quiet enough to see things objectively. The initial aim of Buddhist meditation must, therefore, be to calm the mind and thus achieve a more objective and accurate perception of reality.
To achieve success in meditation, ones moral conduct should be much better than average. Moral transgressions always occur because of the mental defilements, which meditation aims to remove. For intensive retreats it is essential for meditators to observe chastity and to abstain from sensual enjoyments like music and entertainment. The beginner should at least abstain from immoral behaviour and indulgence in intoxicating drinks and drugs.
The Practice of Mindfulness
The meditation method taught by the Buddha is called Satipatthana or mindfulness meditation. This simple but profound technique removes greed, hatred and delusion by the application of systematic and sustained mindfulness to ones own mental and physical processes. To begin the practice of Satipatthana one must focus the mind first on the body. One method widely used is to contemplate the rising and falling of the abdomen as one breathes in and out. This method is suitable for a beginner because the abdominal movement is always present and easily located (by placing the hand on the belly if necessary). The movement of the abdomen should be noticed continuously from beginning to end. Though beginners will not succeed at once, they should try their best to concentrate on the movement.
The traditional posture for sitting meditation is that seen in many images of the Buddha cross-legged with a straight back, the eyes half-closed and the hands resting in the lap. Long experience has shown this to be the most suitable posture. However, you may also meditate sitting on a chair if you support your back and keep it straight. In either case it is important not to change the position frequently, if at all, since every movement will interrupt concentration.
After sitting for some time you may feel some stiffness or pain in the body, or your legs may become numb. This feeling should be noted as stiffness, pain, or numbness. After noting it two or three times you should return to noting the primary object the rising and falling of the abdomen. This noting of feelings is the second aspect of mindfulness meditation.
Although you have been asked to concentrate on the rising and falling of the abdomen, you will probably find that the mind often wanders to other things. You may start to think about something you did yesterday or something you plan to do tomorrow. Whatever thought arises should be noted as thinking, planning, or remembering, whichever is appropriate. Mindfulness does not mean to think about something; the correct technique for a meditator is to note whatever mental or physical process arises, the instant that it occurs. When no other object is distinct, one should return to noting the primary object. One should try to note every mental or physical event without fail. Noting of thoughts is the third aspect of mindfulness meditation.
Hindrances to Concentration
It is not at all easy for a beginner to focus the mind on the meditation object. Even quite experienced meditators experience plenty of mental distractions and aches and pains. Concentration must be developed gradually and, depending on how strong the mental defilements are, this may be a slow and painful process. In particular five things will hinder the development of concentration.
The first is sensual desire. Thoughts of lust or other sensual enjoyments may invade the mind and distract it from the task in hand. This desire should be noted as desire.
The second is ill-will or aversion. It may be memories of some quarrel, aversion to noise or to some pain or discomfort in the body. Such aversion should simply be noted as aversion or anger.
The third is sloth or laziness. For whatever reason, one may become bored or sleepy, one may think that one is too tired to meditate and wish to postpone it. This should be noted as laziness or dullness.
Alternatively, one may become restless and frustrated with ones inability to keep the mind concentrated on the primary object of the rising and falling movements, however hard one tries. This fourth hindrance should be noted as restlessness.
Fifthly, one may have doubts about the value of practising this technique of meditation or about ones own ability to do so. These thoughts should just be noted as doubting.
If one notes these mental hindrances patiently, they can be overcome, then one can continue noting as described before. If one fails to note these hindrances, one may give up the practice without achieving the benefit that is to be expected. If one notes systematically and persistently in the way I have outlined, the mind would certainly become calm and concentrated and one would at least gain some superficial benefits. This noting of mental hindrances and other mental states is the fourth aspect of mindfulness meditation.
When people talk about meditation they often have a mental picture of a yogi sitting in the lotus position, perhaps in a cave or under a tree. However, the Buddhas discourse on mindfulness the Satipatthana Sutta also includes mindfulness during all activities. Insight or enlightenment can equally well arise in other positions. The Buddhas personal attendant, Venerable Änanda, achieved enlightenment during the process of lying down, after practising walking meditation for the whole night.
The way to practise walking meditation is to walk back and forth between two points 16ft or so is sufficient. A meditator should walk extremely slowly, noting each part of the step: lifting the foot, moving forward, dropping the foot, pressing the foot down. Do not look at the feet or look around here and there. Gaze at a point about 6ft in front of the feet, keeping the head erect but the eyes downcast. Let the hands hang together in front of or behind the body. On reaching the end of the walking path note as: stopping, turning, turning, standing, intending to walk. Then continue noting lifting, moving, dropping, pressing as before. Do not make any movement without mindfulness.
If, while walking, you hear a sound, do not look up. Stop walking, note hearing, hearing, then resume walking. If you see something or someone out of the corner of your eye, do not look up. Stop walking, note seeing, seeing, then resume walking. If your mind wanders, stop walking, note wandering or thinking then resume walking.
When you have finished walking and want to sit for meditation, do not just go and sit down at once. Note every action involved in going and sitting down, bending the legs, etc. If you practise continuously like this, the mindfulness developed in walking will be carried over to sitting, and so concentration will develop more steadily.
Walking meditation has many benefits and is in no way inferior to sitting meditation. Sitting may be better for tranquillity, but excessive calm is a fertile ground for sloth and torpor. Walking arouses energy and keen mindfulness. The best policy is to alternate the two one hour walking, one hour sitting, or half-an-hour of each.
Mindfulness in Daily Activities
We cannot spend our whole time in walking and sitting meditation, not even on a meditation retreat. We have to eat, wash, clean our teeth, use the bathroom, etc. These activities should not be regarded as a break from meditation. To maintain the momentum of mindfulness developed in walking and sitting it is vital to note in detail all movements and actions involved in daily activities. For example, in eating, the meditator should note: lifting the food, opening the mouth, putting in the food, chewing, tasting, swallowing, lowering the hand, reaching for more food, etc. Every morsel of food should be taken mindfully in this way.
The meditator should slow down all activities as much as possible and note them in detail. However, if it is necessary to do something somewhat quickly (for example, if there is only one bathroom shared by many meditators, or if shopping must be bought) it should be done quickly with general mindfulness, not with precise and detailed noting.
Talking is a Great Hindrance
It is also advised in the Satipatthana Sutta to be mindful in speaking and in remaining silent. When engaged in intensive meditation, one should avoid talking altogether. Five minutes chat can spoil a whole days effort in meditation. A single word spoken in anger can do even more harm. Even when it is time to report to the teacher, the meditator should speak briefly and straight to the point.
Continuity is the Secret of Success
Developing insight through meditation has been compared to making fire by rubbing two sticks together. To succeed, effort must be both vigorous and continuous. Anyone can succeed in meditation except one person a lazy meditator is hopeless! Do not be discouraged if results fail to appear at once. During a period of intensive meditation, one is bound to experience many ups and downs. At times, the mind will be overwhelmed by one or other of the five hindrances. When the mind is obscured by unwholesome mental states then it is inconceivable that deep insight could arise one might as well try swimming with a suitcase. However, if one contemplates these unwholesome mental states instead of indulging in them, one will come to realise their conditioned and impermanent nature. In time, the mind will become buoyant again, then clear mindfulness and deep concentration can be re-established. This is a very important point:
All mental and physical phenomena must be contemplated to comprehend their true nature, not to make them go away.
The Benefits of Meditation
Long before enlightenment is reached, mindfulness will give its results. Like a bank account, the more you put into it the more interest you will get. When the mind becomes interested in the meditation object, you can achieve some insight into the true nature of the mental and physical process. If mindfulness is sustained and concentration is deep enough, the mental defilements, which prevent one from experiencing real happiness, will be removed, at least temporarily. At such times, one can enjoy subtle bliss never experienced before. Many doubts and conflicts can be resolved by this kind of experience, which is direct and empirical.
I am often asked, "How much meditation should I do?" The answer depends on who is asking the question. We can make an analogy with jogging. How much should one practise jogging if one wants to get fit? It depends on how fit you are already and how fit you want to be. If you are a couch-potato, it would be unwise to begin by doing 5 miles a day; as little as ¼ mile might be enough to start with. However, if you are quite athletic and want to run in the London marathon next year, 5 miles a day might be about right. However, if you want to win the marathon, it certainly would not be enough.
Meditation aims to train the undisciplined mind to make it fit for life. It helps us to cope with stress and to develop our intelligence and concentration span. The more time we can spare to devote to meditation practice the better, but it must be fitted in between other responsibilities. Even a working housewife with a family could probably still manage to spend 15 minutes every day for sitting meditation. If you make a point of carrying out your daily routine with sustained mindfulness, just that much can be an excellent way to develop the practice.
As a rough guide for someone who sincerely wishes to progress in meditation, I would suggest the following as a sensible schedule. Every day, try to set aside one hour for meditation. This can be in two half-hour sessions, morning and evening. At weekends, visit a meditation centre for one longer session say, two or three consecutive hours. Once a month, try to attend a weekend retreat. Every year, attend a longer, and more intensive, residential retreat for one or two weeks.
How can Progress be Measured?
It is usually a mistake to try to measure progress in meditation. When the mind is very calm and peaceful, we are inclined to think that we are making progress. Conversely, when the mind is restless and full of defilements, we might think that the meditation is not so good. However, the main purpose of meditation is to remove defilements and not just to get peaceful. Since the meditators mind will not usually be very pure to begin with, suppressed impurities will be brought up to the surface through meditation. Anyone can be cheerful when allowed to do whatever he or she wants. However, if the meditation teacher urges one to practise for many hours without a break, then all kinds of defilements will appear. Meditators should recognise the five hindrances as a sure sign of progress, but if they fail to note them precisely as instructed these very same hindrances will become obstructions to progress. If one persistently notes the hindrances of desire, ill-will, restlessness, drowsiness and doubt, whenever they arise, there will come a stage when they subside. The mind will then settle on the primary object of meditation the rising and falling of the abdomen. Then we can say that the meditator has made some progress, can't we?
In the early stages of the practice, the mind settles down on the primary object only for short periods. For example, one can clearly note the rising but not the falling, or vice versa. Alternatively, one can clearly note the middle of each but not the beginning or the end. However, with more practice, one can distinctly notice the whole process of rising, the whole process of falling, and the short gaps between each process. Then we can also say that the meditator has made some progress since before he or she could only notice part of the rising and falling.
Inexperienced meditators may become elated with these signs of progress. They may experience feelings of bliss when they enjoy the tranquil process of the quiet mind just observing the simple abdominal movement. At this stage, distractions like noise or discomfort may occasionally intrude. However, the meditator can note them and the mind obediently returns to the rising and falling. These feelings of bliss or elation should be noted carefully too, or they may mislead the beginner. If, after meditating for one full day, meditators get such experiences, they go to bed on cloud nine. The next morning they get up before dawn to continue as instructed and find that the defilements have returned in full force. "Last night my concentration was so good but this morning I am too tired to meditate, perhaps I should go back to bed for another hour". So maybe (if the teacher is not looking) they go back to bed and wake up when the gong goes for breakfast. Then after breakfast they feel more sleepy than ever.
At this point, the meditator may become very dejected and want to give up meditation, or even to run away from the retreat centre. It is because they failed to note the feelings of elation properly. Elation is so delightful that one easily gets attached to it and longs to repeat it. Longing, or craving, is one of the hindrances, so one must remember to note both pleasant and unpleasant feelings objectively. The more experienced meditator will not be unbalanced by these inevitable fluctuations in the quality of concentration. When the meditator is more mature and does not easily get elated or depressed then we can say that he or she has made further progress.
This booklet is just an introduction to meditation so I will not explain about deeper stages of insight. One should seek out an experienced teacher for guidance in meditation. To attain the deep insight which leads to enlightenment requires commitment and dedication. It helps a lot to have an attitude of reverence and humility though one should also retain a healthy scepticism. The cynic, however, will never understand the Dhamma, which can be realised only by the wise. The mere fact that Buddhism has survived for more than 2,500 years points to the validity of its teaching. The discerning seeker from any religious tradition can find in its teachings invaluable guidance for leading a rewarding and contented life. However, the practice of mindfulness leading to liberation is the core of the Buddhas teaching.
What is Buddhism?
Buddhism is different things to different people. To some, Buddhism is the religion founded by Gotama Buddha 2,500 years ago, which is now practised in many countries of the world, such as Burma, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Tibet, Japan, China, etc. However, to someone from a non-Buddhist culture, it is obvious that the interpretation and practice of Buddhism in these various countries differs significantly.
If one sincerely wishes to know what Buddhism is, therefore, one must take the trouble to find out what the Buddha taught. The Buddha advised people not to believe something just because it is held to be true by many people, or because it is handed down by tradition, or because it is the teaching of a renowned teacher. He advised that one should consider whether it is for ones own benefit and the benefit of others, and if so, one should accept it and follow it.
The Buddha was not a god, nor a prophet sent by God. He was born a human being, but one of extraordinary wisdom and compassion. He perceived the universal suffering of humanity and resolved to find a cure. To find it he renounced his comfortable life as a prince and lived the life of an ascetic recluse. By deep meditation or introspection he discovered the root cause of unhappiness within the mind and simultaneously realised how to remove this cause and hence to find perfect peace.
He found craving to be the root cause. He taught that to remove it one must follow the path of insight meditation founded on a firm foundation of blameless moral conduct.
This method can be followed by anyone, whatever their belief. If one has some confidence in the method and practises it strenuously, the benefits will follow. Buddhism is not a system of belief though many doctrines can be found in its teachings. Nor is it a religion if by religion is meant a traditional observance of rituals and ceremonies. Primarily, Buddhism is a method of mental training and self-discipline. Its aim is to gain insight into the mental and physical processes that make up what we call a living being, in order to develop detachment, objectivity and wisdom. Without wisdom one cannot understand the profound teaching of the Buddha. Without the practice of meditation one cannot be wise, and without wisdom one will not be inclined to practise meditation.
Whether one grows in wisdom or not depends on ones own efforts. Mere worship of others, however wise they might be, will not develop wisdom. Anyway, if someone is not wise, how would he know if others are wise or foolish? Wisdom must be cultivated through ones own inner experience and understanding of the human condition. Cultivating wisdom can be compared to cultivating crops. One cannot force crops to grow, but one can provide the best possible conditions by removing weeds and by providing plenty of fertiliser, water and sunlight. If one removes the weeds of immoral conduct and unwholesome thoughts, if one studies and listens to teaching on the Dhamma, if one makes strenuous efforts in meditation, if one practises tolerance and loving-kindness, then wisdom will inevitably develop though its growth may not be easily discernible. Day-by-day, and from moment-to-moment we have to cultivate mindfulness; only this, and no amount of prayer or wishful thinking, can produce the desired result.
The Buddha showed the way that leads to perfect peace, but it is up to each individual to fulfil the conditions that will enable him or her to realise the same peace for himself or herself. Though the way is not easy, each step taken is one step nearer to the goal, and the benefits follow immediately. To attain the perfect peace of nibbäna there is no need to wait for death.
The goal of nibbäna is extremely subtle. People are generally obsessed by the pursuit of pleasant feelings, or by avoiding unpleasant ones. So the absence of feeling may be imagined as some kind of annihilation or self-denial. Yet feeling is like a raging inferno, consuming all fuel with which it comes into contact. Satisfaction is impossible to achieve by running after feelings. If you spend a few hours in meditation, you can appreciate the peace that comes from not feeding this fire. Then you could perhaps imagine what it would be like to be totally cool!
Practising meditation is like pouring cold water on the fire. Gradually the heat of craving will be reduced and the mind will become more serene. However, practice must be persistent; if you stop pouring water onto the fire and resume heaping on fuel as before, craving will soon reassert itself. Continuity is the secret of success in meditation. First learn the technique, then work hard to improve it. Once you are on the right track, practise repeatedly until practice makes perfect.
"The mind is difficult to control; swift and fickle, it flits wherever it pleases. To tame the mind is good, for a well-tamed mind brings happiness."
"Not by a shower of gold coins can sensual pleasures be satiated; sensual pleasures give little satisfaction and are fraught with evil consequences. Knowing this, the wise man, the disciple of the Buddha, does not delight even in heavenly pleasures, but rejoices in the cessation of craving (nibbäna)."
(Dhammapada vv 35, 186, 187)
|( First published by the 'Association for Insight Meditation')|
This page at Nibbana.com was last modified: